Sources: criticism

Links to things I want to remember

Ted Gioia: Why Did the Beatles Get So Many Bad Reviews?

Friday, February 3rd, 2023

A great cautionary essay on the critic’s reactions to first performances of music we now consider classic or great or revolutionary, from Jazz to the Beatles to Beethoven. The upshot: when something is different and innovative it usually gets a bad first review. The Beatle’s albums were all different from each other, each one a fresh, innovative experiment; therefore, most of their first reviews were bad. Amazing reflection on the folly of history.